When You’ve Been Fighting About the Same Thing for Years
Key Takeaways
- Many recurring conflicts in relationships are rarely about the surface topic, such as laundry, finances, or household chores, but rather stem from unexpressed emotional needs.
- Drawing from James 4:1, the root of quarrels often originates from internal desires waging war within us before we ever raise our voices to another person.
- Stephanie Boose and her husband Duane experienced this firsthand in their early marriage, constantly cycling through arguments until they recognized their true underlying patterns.
- A relationship loop requires two people to maintain it; when one person stops reacting from the same defensive place, the cycle loses its momentum.
- Instead of demanding that a spouse or friend fulfill unmet needs they were never built to supply, believers should bring those deep desires directly to God first.
You know when it's starting and how it ends, and nothing changes. Learn what James refuses to do when a church brings him their fights, and the one question to ask yourself instead.
Some couples and some friends have the same argument every few months. The topic changes and the pattern holds. You know when it's starting, and you know what each of you is about to say. Then the fight ends the way it always ends, either resolved or shelved, and nothing is different. Here's why resolving the topic never fixes it. Both of you are arguing about the surface, and the surface is almost never what the fight is about.
This episode opens with Stephanie and Duane, who had the same fight over and over in the first two years of their marriage. They'd blended two families and argued about the kids and money, and about whether it was her job to put away a basket of laundry she had already washed and folded. Every few weeks it came back. Different topic, same fight.
James 4:1 asks, "What is causing the quarrels and fights among you? Don't they come from the evil desires at war within you?" Look at what James refuses to do. He never asks what they're fighting about, and he takes no sides on any of the topics. He asks where the fighting comes from, then answers his own question by pointing inside the people doing it.
Then look at the phrase at war within you. The Greek is a military word for running a campaign, the kind with supply lines and winter quarters. It points past any skirmish between a husband and a wife to an operation already underway inside one person, before anybody raises a voice.
Verse 2 tells you what the campaign is over. You want what you don't have, James says, and then comes the line that does more for a recurring fight than any communication tip: yet you don't have what you want because you don't ask God for it. The want is legitimate, and he tells them they've been going after it down a road that can't deliver it. In your case that road is a person at your kitchen table who was never built to supply the thing.
Stephanie wanted to be heard, which is a good want. She went after it by handing Duane every bit of stress she had, which got her a fixer when she needed a listener. So when you feel it starting, ask yourself a different question. What do I want right now that I'm not getting. Then take that to God before you take your complaint to the person.
Here's the mechanical part. A loop needs two people running their parts, so when one person stops reacting from the same place, the loop has nothing to run on.
Bart shares his own version of this, years across the table from couples in this loop and the admission that hearing the pattern from a chair across the room is a different skill than hearing it when you're in it.
BY THE TIME YOU FINISH LISTENING, YOU'LL DISCOVER:
What James refuses to do when a church brings him their fights The military word behind "at war within you" and what it says about timing One question to ask yourself the next time you feel the fight starting
The surface topic is almost never what the fight is about underneath. Ask God to show you the real source of your anger, and bring it to Him before you bring it to the other person.
Story source. Stephanie Boose's account of her marriage to Duane, published by FamilyLife as "We Couldn't Stop Arguing." The Weekend to Remember conference they attended was in September 2006.
Share This Episode:
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/352
Need Prayer? Leave me a voicemail:
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/voicemail
Want to keep these devotions coming? Please consider supporting this podcast.
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/support/
Rate and Review
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/reviews/new/
Connect with Bart
Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/dailydevotionsforbusylives
Website: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com
Feeling spiritually drained? Start here. Download your free copy of my eBook Making Time for Jesus here: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/subscribe.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do couples keep having the same argument over and over?
Recurring arguments usually persist because partners focus entirely on surface issues like chores or money instead of addressing the deeper, unexpressed emotional wants underneath.
What does James 4:1 say about fights and quarrels?
James 4:1 explains that quarrels originate from the desires waging war within us, pointing inward to personal inner campaigns rather than outward to the immediate trigger.
How did Stephanie Boose stop the cycle of arguments in her marriage?
Stephanie Boose stopped the argument loop by identifying her true need to be heard rather than fixed, changing her response, and turning to God instead of leaning too heavily on her husband for stress relief.
How can you break a recurring argument loop with your spouse?
You can break the loop by changing your own part in the interaction, refusing to react from the same old triggers, and asking God for what you need before bringing a complaint to your partner.
Track 1 00:00:01
In the first two years of their marriage, Stephanie and
Track 1 00:00:03
Duane had the same fight over and over. They'd blended two
Track 1 00:00:08
families, and they argued about the kids and money and about
Track 1 00:00:11
whether it was her job to put away a basket of laundry she had
Track 1 00:00:14
already washed and folded. Every few weeks, it came back.
Track 1 00:00:18
Different topic, same fight. She would raise her voice, and he
Track 1 00:00:22
would try to fix it. Nothing ever changed. They loved each
Track 1 00:00:26
other, and they couldn't break the loop. The truth was, the
Track 1 00:00:29
laundry was never the problem. Stephanie was fighting about
Track 1 00:00:32
something she hadn't put into words yet. We'll come back to
Track 1 00:00:36
what Stephanie learned, but first, welcome to Daily
Track 1 00:00:41
Devotions for Busy Lives. I'm Bart Léger. I've counseled a
Track 1 00:00:45
few couples in this exact loop. After enough years, you already
Track 1 00:00:49
expect what you're going to hear. They'll be telling me about the
Track 1 00:00:53
dishes or the calendar, and I already know the fight isn't
Track 1 00:00:56
about either one. Some couples and some friends have the same
Track 1 00:00:59
argument every few months. The topic changes, and the pattern
Track 1 00:01:02
stays the same. You know when it's starting. You know what
Track 1 00:01:05
each of you is about to say before each of you says it. And
Track 1 00:01:09
then the fight ends the way it always ends, either resolved or
Track 1 00:01:12
shelved, and nothing's different. Three months later, you're in it
Track 1 00:01:15
again over something else. Here's why resolving the topic
Track 1 00:01:18
never fixes it. Both of you are arguing about the surface issue,
Track 1 00:01:24
and the surface is almost never about what the fight's about. So,
Track 1 00:01:27
you settle the laundry, and the laundry was never the account
Track 1 00:01:30
that needed settling. stop going at each other. James 4.1 What is
Track 1 00:01:38
causing the quarrels and fights among you? Don't they come from
Track 1 00:01:41
the evil desires at war within you? Look at what James refuses
Track 1 00:01:46
to do. He never asks what they're fighting about. James
Track 1 00:01:50
had to know the topics, and he doesn't take them up or take
Track 1 00:01:54
sides on any of them. He asks where the fighting comes from,
Track 1 00:01:57
and then he answers his own question by pointing inside the
Track 1 00:02:00
people doing it. Then look at the phrase at war within you.
Track 1 00:02:05
The Greek there is a military word for running a campaign, the
Track 1 00:02:08
kind that goes on for a long stretch with supply lines and
Track 1 00:02:11
winter quarters. The word points past any skirmish a husband and
Track 1 00:02:16
a wife to an operation already underway inside one person
Track 1 00:02:20
before anybody raises a voice. Keep reading into verse 2, where
Track 1 00:02:24
James tells you what the campaign is over. You want what
Track 1 00:02:27
you don't have, he says. Then comes the line that does more
Track 1 00:02:31
for a recurring fight than any communication tip. He says, yet
Track 1 00:02:34
you don't have what you want because you don't ask God for it.
Track 1 00:02:38
Here's what he grants there. The want's legitimate. James doesn't
Track 1 00:02:42
tell them to stop wanting. He tells them they've been going
Track 1 00:02:45
after it down a road that can't deliver it, which in your case
Track 1 00:02:48
is a person at your kitchen table or maybe the coffee shop
Track 1 00:02:52
who was never built to supply the thing. Stephanie wanted to
Track 1 00:02:55
be heard. That's a good want. She was going after it by
Track 1 00:02:59
handing Dwayne every bit of stress she had, which got her a
Track 1 00:03:03
fixer when she needed a listener. That made her angrier, and the
Track 1 00:03:07
fight started again. So when you start feeling it, ask yourself a
Track 1 00:03:11
different question than the one you've been asking. What do I
Track 1 00:03:14
want right now that I'm not getting? Then take that answer
Track 1 00:03:18
to God before you take your complaint to the person. Verse 2
Track 1 00:03:21
again. You don't have what you want because you don't ask God
Track 1 00:03:25
for it. Here's the working part. A loop needs two people running
Track 1 00:03:29
their parts. When one person stops reacting in the same place,
Track 1 00:03:33
the loop has nothing to run on. You don't have to get your
Track 1 00:03:36
spouse to to anything, which is good because you've already
Track 1 00:03:41
tried that for years. At a marriage conference, something
Track 1 00:03:44
shifted for Stephanie. She saw her part in it. For years, she'd
Track 1 00:03:48
handed Dwayne every kind of stress and leaned on him like a
Track 1 00:03:51
crutch, then gotten angry when he did what came naturally to
Track 1 00:03:56
him, which was to try to fix it or try to fix her. What she
Track 1 00:04:00
wanted was for him to simply hear her. So she changed her
Track 1 00:04:05
part first. instead of firing back. to vent, she'd tell him, I
Track 1 00:04:10
don't need you to fix this for me. I just want you to listen.
Track 1 00:04:14
She stopped making her husband the one who had to handle all of
Track 1 00:04:17
it, and she leaned on God instead. The arguments didn't
Track 1 00:04:21
completely disappear, but the loop did, because one person
Track 1 00:04:24
stopped reacting from the same place. Stephanie says God is the
Track 1 00:04:27
one who healed their marriage, and it started the day she
Track 1 00:04:30
brought the thing she was angry about to him first, before she
Track 1 00:04:34
brought it to Dwayne. Stephanie admits she still disagrees with
Track 1 00:04:37
her husband. What ended was the part where every disagreement
Track 1 00:04:40
turned into the same fight with the same ending. Here's today's
Track 1 00:04:44
challenge. Write down the last three fights you had with this
Track 1 00:04:47
person. Different topics probably. the same in all three,
Track 1 00:04:52
because there's probably something. Then finish this
Track 1 00:04:55
sentence. What I want from them and can't seem to get is,
Track 1 00:04:59
however that comes out, it's closer to the truth than any of
Track 1 00:05:02
the topics were. Take that to God and ask Him for it. He can
Track 1 00:05:06
hand you some of it directly, and He can show you how much
Track 1 00:05:09
you've been demanding from someone who doesn't have it to
Track 1 00:05:12
give. Father, You told us through James that our fights
Track 1 00:05:15
come from a war inside us before they ever reach anybody else.
Track 1 00:05:19
Thank You that You don't require us to win an argument before we
Track 1 00:05:22
can come to You. For everybody listening who's tired of having
Track 1 00:05:25
the same fight, show them what they've been wanting and going
Track 1 00:05:28
after the wrong way. Give them the courage to change their own
Track 1 00:05:31
part first. In Jesus' name, Amen. This podcast runs on the
Track 1 00:05:37
generosity of listeners just like you. If Daily Devotions for
Track 1 00:05:40
Busy Lives has encouraged you, would you consider supporting it
Track 1 00:05:43
with a one-time gift or by becoming a monthly supporter?
Track 1 00:05:46
Every contribution helps keep these devotions coming every
Track 1 00:05:50
week. You can give at dailydevotionsforbusylives.com
Track 1 00:05:54
slash support. Thank you so much. And thanks for joining me on
Track 1 00:05:58
Daily Devotions for Busy Lives. Remember, James sent them
Track 1 00:06:02
looking inward before he let them settle anything with each
Track 1 00:06:05
other. Ask God for what you've been trying to get from a person.
Track 1 00:06:09
Come back next time for more encouragement to help you live
Track 1 00:06:12
grounded in God's truth. Until then, God bless and have a great
Track 1 00:06:16
day.
