How to Love Someone Whose Choices You Don't Agree With

This episode explores how to love someone making choices you disagree with, drawing on 1 Peter 4:8. It presents a 'third way' beyond silence or confrontation: a love that grieves the choice while continuing to love the person, using prayer as its engine. Real-life stories illustrate how this approach can lead to transformation.
Key Takeaways
- When loved ones make choices you can't celebrate, the instinct is to either stay silent or confront, but 1 Peter 4:8 offers a 'third way' of deep love.
- Love 'covers a multitude of sins' by continuing to love the person while still acknowledging their wrong choices, refusing to approve or cut them off.
- This 'third way' involves holding the tension of grieving the choice and loving the person simultaneously, as these are not mutually exclusive.
- Prayer is presented as the essential engine for this covering love, enabling you to love the person and ask God to act where you cannot.
- Practical application includes performing a 'warm thing' to show continued presence and taking your concerns to God in prayer.
In the delicate dance of relationships, we often find ourselves at a crossroads when a loved one makes choices that deeply trouble us. Two common instincts pull us in opposing directions: the urge to remain silent and observe, or the impulse to confront and correct. This episode of Daily Devotions for Busy Lives explores a profound third way, illuminated by the wisdom of 1 Peter 4:8 – a path of love that grieves the choice while steadfastly cherishing the person, all without severing the connection.
When someone you love errs in judgment, or embarks on a path you foresee will lead to harm, you can feel torn. The instinct to preserve peace might whisper, "Say nothing and let them go; speaking up could push them further away." Conversely, another voice urges confrontation, demanding they "see the truth." Both approaches, however, leave us feeling unsettled. Silence can feel like tacit approval, while confrontation risks alienating the very person we care about. We often oscillate between these two extremes, rarely finding a sense of peace.
The Apostle Peter offers a more courageous and sustainable path. In 1 Peter 4:8, he writes, "Most important of all, continue to show deep love for each other, for love covers a multitude of sins." In this context, "to cover" doesn't mean to ignore or condone wrongdoing. Instead, it signifies a persistent, active love that walks alongside a person through their struggles, acknowledging the sin for what it is without judgment or condemnation, and without cutting off the relationship. This approach refuses the easy exits of feigned approval or outright rejection. It calls us to the braver act of remaining in the relationship, consistently demonstrating that our love is unconditional and not something that needs to be re-earned.
This principle is powerfully illustrated by the story of Angela Yuan and her son, Christopher. When Christopher came out and subsequently spiraled into drug use and dealing, Angela was heartbroken. She could not pretend to approve of his choices, yet she steadfastly refused to cut him off. Instead, she committed to years of prayer and fasting every Monday, her knees growing calloused from her devotion. Throughout this time, she continued to write and visit Christopher, her love a constant presence that neither affirmed his destructive behavior nor declared him beyond redemption. Years later, in a prison cell, Christopher discovered a Bible, began to read, and ultimately returned to God. Today, he dedicates his life to teaching the Bible to others.
Angela’s journey, and many others, highlight that this "covering love" intentionally holds tension. It allows us to grieve the harmful choices made while simultaneously loving the person, recognizing that these two sentiments are not mutually exclusive. The driving force behind this resilient love is prayer. When we feel powerless to effect change in another person's life, and we've chosen not to resort to badgering, prayer becomes the vital conduit through which our love continues its work. We can continue to love the person before us, entrusting God with the aspects of their life that are beyond our control.
In this episode, Dr. Bart Leger shares a deeply personal account of navigating similar challenges with his own oldest son during a period of drinking and spiritual drift. Bart and his wife, Katharine, chose to love their son without hounding him, instead praying boldly for God's intervention. This unwavering love and persistent prayer ultimately led their son back to faith, and he now actively leads worship in their church. This experience underscores a vital truth: it is possible to grieve someone's choices and love them concurrently. These two responses are not adversaries; often, maintaining closeness is precisely how God works most profoundly.
As you listen, you'll gain insight into:
- The internal conflict and emotional pull when loved ones make choices you cannot endorse.
- The profound meaning of love "covering a multitude of sins" as described in 1 Peter 4:8.
- A practical "third way" to engage with loved ones that involves staying connected and praying, rather than succumbing to silence or confrontation.
This episode encourages us to embrace a love that grieves choices yet cherishes the person, trusting that God's work in their life is often facilitated by our persistent presence and prayer. These two aspects—grieving a choice and loving a person—are not enemies; in fact, maintaining that close connection is frequently the most potent tool God uses for transformation.
Share This Episode: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/276
Need Prayer? Leave me a voicemail: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/voicemail
Support This Podcast: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/support/
Rate and Review: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/reviews/new/
Connect with Bart:
Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/dailydevotionsforbusylives
Website: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com
Feeling spiritually drained? Download your free copy of my eBook Making Time for Jesus here: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/subscribe.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I love someone whose choices I strongly disagree with?
The episode suggests a 'third way' beyond silence or confrontation: maintain deep love for the person while grieving their choices. This involves staying connected, not pretending to approve, and relying on prayer to work in their life.
What does 'love covers a multitude of sins' mean in this context?
According to 1 Peter 4:8 and the episode's explanation, it means to continue loving a person through their sinful or harmful choices without condoning the behavior. It means keeping the relationship intact while still addressing the truth.
What are the two common, but often ineffective, reactions to a loved one's bad choices?
The two common instincts are to either say nothing to keep the peace (which can feel like endorsement) or to confront them directly (which can drive them away). Both leave you unsettled.
How can prayer help when dealing with someone's choices I can't change?
Prayer is the engine of covering love. When you can't change someone and choose not to badger them, prayer allows your love to continue working. You entrust the person and the situation to God's power and intervention.
Can I express disapproval of someone's choices while still loving them?
Absolutely. The episode emphasizes that you can grieve a person's choices and love them at the same time. Staying close and loving them without needing them to earn your love back is often the most effective approach, supported by prayer.
When Christopher Nguyen was 23, he sat his
Bart Leger:Chinese immigrant parents down and told him he was gay. His mom,
Bart Leger:Angela, gave him a choice: the family or that. So Christopher
Bart Leger:left, and on his way out, he told him his gay friends were
Bart Leger:his family now. Then things got worse. He partied his way out of
Bart Leger:dental school three months short of his degree and moved to
Bart Leger:Atlanta, where he started using drugs and then selling them. For
Bart Leger:a long time, Angela barely knew where he was or whether he was
Bart Leger:even alive. She was heartbroken over the road her son was on,
Bart Leger:and she couldn't pretend she approved of it. She also refused
Bart Leger:to cut him off, even though that might have felt justified. So
Bart Leger:there she was, a mother who couldn't celebrate her son's
Bart Leger:choices and couldn't stop loving her son. Two things at once
Bart Leger:pulling in opposite directions. And from that far away, with a
Bart Leger:son who had told her his friends were his family now, she had
Bart Leger:almost nothing left to work with. Almost. We'll come back to what
Bart Leger:she had, but first,
Bart Leger:welcome to Daily Devotions for Busy Lives. I'm Bart LeJay. If
Bart Leger:you love someone who's making choices you can't celebrate, I
Bart Leger:want to speak to the tension you've been living in. And I
Bart Leger:know this tension personally. When our oldest son was younger,
Bart Leger:he started drinking. And for a while, he wasn't living for the
Bart Leger:Lord the way we'd raised him to. Catherine and I chose to keep
Bart Leger:loving him without hounding him about it. And then, we prayed a
Bart Leger:bold prayer, "God, do whatever it takes to bring him back to
Bart Leger:you." It wasn't quick, and it wasn't easy to "But he
Bart Leger:eventually came back. Today, that same son is our worship
Bart Leger:leader, serving God any way he can. So when I talk about loving
Bart Leger:someone through choices that break your heart, I'm not
Bart Leger:speaking from theory. Here's the bind a lot of us are in. Someone
Bart Leger:we love—maybe it's a child, maybe a close friend—is making
Bart Leger:choices we believe are sinful, or that we're sure will
Bart Leger:eventually hurt them. Two instincts start pulling in
Bart Leger:opposite directions. The first says to keep the peace, say
Bart Leger:nothing and watch them go, because speaking up might push
Bart Leger:further off. The second says to confront them and make them see
Bart Leger:the truth. Both leave you unsettled. Silence feels like
Bart Leger:you're endorsing it. Confrontation feels like you're
Bart Leger:driving them away. Most of us bounce between the two and
Bart Leger:really feel right about either. The Apostle Peter points to a
Bart Leger:third way, and I believe it's better than either of those.
Bart Leger:Listen to what he wrote in 1 Peter 4: 8, "Most important of
Bart Leger:all, continue to show deep love for each other; for love covers
Bart Leger:a multitude of sins." Think closely at that phrase, "Love
Bart Leger:covers a multitude of sins." To cover, here, means to keep
Bart Leger:loving a person right through their sin while still calling
Bart Leger:the sin what it is. That's the third way, and it removes both
Bart Leger:easy exits. You don't have to pretend you approve, and you
Bart Leger:don't have to cut them off to make your point. Keep showing
Bart Leger:that your love isn't a reward. You get to do the braver, the
Bart Leger:better thing. Stay in the relationship, and keep showing
Bart Leger:that your love isn't a reward they have to earn back. Both of
Bart Leger:those old instincts seem to end the tension quickly. One, by
Bart Leger:pretending, and the other by pushing. Covering love holds the
Bart Leger:tension on purpose. It lets you grieve the choice and to love
Bart Leger:the person in the same breath because those two were never
Bart Leger:really opposites. Angela proved it. She never told Christopher
Bart Leger:his lifestyle was fine, and she never told him he was too far
Bart Leger:gone. She just kept loving from her knees for years. And don't
Bart Leger:miss what works together with that love. It's prayer. When you
Bart Leger:can't change someone, and you've decided not to badger them,
Bart Leger:prayer is where your love keeps working. It's what Catherine and
Bart Leger:I did, and it's what Angela did for years. "You keep loving the
Bart Leger:person, and you keep asking God to do the part you can't." What
Bart Leger:she had was her knees. After nearly losing her own life to
Bart Leger:despair, Angela had come to Christ, and she started praying
Bart Leger:for Christopher like it was her job. She fasted every Monday for
Bart Leger:seven years, and one stretch she went 39 days straight. Her knees
Bart Leger:turned brown and calloused from kneeling in her prayer closet.
Bart Leger:And the whole time, she kept writing and visiting, and her
Bart Leger:love never once told him he was too far gone. A few years
Bart Leger:Christopher was arrested for dealing and sent to prison. And
Bart Leger:there, at what looked like the bottom, he found a Bible someone
Bart Leger:had tossed in a trash can. He started reading. "In a cell with
Bart Leger:an HIV diagnosis and a felony record, the son who had stormed
Bart Leger:out came home to God." Today, he teaches the Bible to others.
Bart Leger:Peter wrote that above everything, we should keep
Bart Leger:loving each other deeply, because love covers a multitude
Bart Leger:of Peter wrote that above all our sins. He means love that
Bart Leger:keeps loving a person through their sin while calling sin what
Bart Leger:it is. It's the love that's consistent, that keeps writing
Bart Leger:the letters and kneeling in the prayer closet long after most
Bart Leger:people would have quit. You can grieve someone's choices and
Bart Leger:love them at the same time. Angela did both for years, and
Bart Leger:God did the rest. Here's today's challenge. Bring to mind the
Bart Leger:person whose choices have been grieving you. Instead of the too
Bart Leger:old instincts, silence or confrontation, choose the third
Bart Leger:way this week. Do one warm thing that says you're still here,
Bart Leger:maybe a text with no agenda about the issue between you.
Bart Leger:Then, take the grief to God the way Angela did. And pray boldly
Bart Leger:for the person asking him to do what you can't. You're not
Bart Leger:endorsing anything, and you're not giving up. You're loving
Bart Leger:them the way God loves you, all the way through. Father, you
Bart Leger:know the people we love who are making choices that break our
Bart Leger:hearts. Thank you that your own love covers us the same way,
Bart Leger:staying close while we're still a mess. Give us that kind of
Bart Leger:love for them, the love that grieves the choice and never
Bart Leger:lets go with a person. Guard us from the silence that pretends
Bart Leger:and the pressure that pushes them away. And do in their lives
Bart Leger:what only you can do, the way you did for Angela's son, and
Bart Leger:for those of us who once ran and came home. In Jesus' name, amen.
Bart Leger:If Daily Devotions for Busy Lives has been an encouragement
Bart Leger:to you, would you take a minute and leave a rating and review?
Bart Leger:It helps more people find these devotions, and it only takes a
Bart Leger:moment. I'd be so grateful. And thanks for joining me on Daily
Bart Leger:Devotions for Busy Lives. Remember, you can grieve
Bart Leger:someone's choices and love them at the same time. Those two
Bart Leger:aren't enemies, and staying close is often what God uses
Bart Leger:most. Come back next time for more encouragement to help you
Bart Leger:live grounded in God's truth. Until then, God bless and have a
Bart Leger:great day.








