What to Do When You're Afraid Your Child Is Dating the Wrong Person
Key Takeaways
- When a child is dating the wrong person, pushing back too hard often backfires and pushes them closer to their partner while distancing them from you.
- Psalm 25:12 shifts how parents should pray, encouraging you to ask God to grant your child discernment and eyes to see clearly rather than just praying against the partner.
- Fifty years of psychological research on the Romeo and Juliet effect shows that parents have a very limited span of control over who their children choose to date.
- When your child is dating someone concerning, the best approach is to stay calm, keep the relational door open, and leave the true work of changing a heart to God.
- Instead of giving unsolicited lectures, wait for natural conversational openings, share strictly what you have noticed, and then stop talking.
You see things your child can't see yet, and every word you say seems to push them further in. Learn what Psalm 25:12 changes about the way you pray, and what fifty years of research says about a parent's leverage.
Few things pull on a parent like watching your child with somebody you're worried about. You see things they can't see yet. You've been around long enough to know how much a partner shapes a life, and you can already picture the next ten years of it. And you're walking a line every day. Say too much and you push them closer to that person and further from you. Say nothing and you feel like you stood there and watched it happen. Most parents end up doing both. You hold it in for weeks, and then it comes out sideways at the supper table in a tone you never planned on using.
This episode opens in 1972, when a team of researchers set out to test something every worried parent wonders about. They tracked dating and married couples for months, watching what happened as families pushed against the match. The numbers seemed to confirm a parent's worst fear. The more the parents disapproved, the more in love the couples said they were. They called it the Romeo and Juliet effect, and for decades the takeaway was that fighting your kid's relationship only pours gas on it.
Psalm 25:12 changes the question a parent brings to God: "Who are those who fear the LORD? He will show them the path they should choose." Look at who does the work in that sentence. He will show them. God does the showing. The path gets revealed to the person walking it, and you aren't the one holding the flashlight.
That ought to change what you ask God for. Most of us pray about the other person. Psalm 25 points somewhere else entirely. Pray that your child can see. Ask God for discernment in your son or daughter, for eyes to recognize what's in front of them and the spine to act on it. That prayer has an advantage the other one doesn't. It never requires you to be right about this person. You might be right. You might also be wrong, and every parent listening knows a family who was dead wrong about somebody.
The door does open sometimes, and when it does, say one thing and keep it to what you've noticed. Then stop, because the stopping is what keeps the door on its hinges. Bart shares his own version of this, the parents who sit across his desk hoping he'll hand them a sentence that makes their kid see it, and what he tells them now instead. As for that 1972 study, later researchers went back to repeat it, and the original story fell apart.
BY THE TIME YOU FINISH LISTENING, YOU'LL DISCOVER:
What happened when researchers tried to replicate the Romeo and Juliet effect How Psalm 25:12 changes what a worried parent prays for One way to speak when the door opens, and when to stop talking
There was no reliable lever a parent could pull. You can pray, and you can speak when the door opens. The work of turning a heart belongs to God.
Share This Episode:
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/334
Need Prayer? Leave me a voicemail:
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/voicemail
Want to keep these devotions coming? Please consider supporting this podcast.
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/support/
Rate and Review
https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/reviews/new/
Connect with Bart
Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/dailydevotionsforbusylives
Website: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com
Feeling spiritually drained? Start here. Download your free copy of my eBook Making Time for Jesus here: https://www.dailydevotionsforbusylives.com/subscribe.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if I think my child is dating the wrong person?
Avoid heavy-handed criticism, which often pushes them further away. Instead, pray for your child's spiritual discernment, keep the lines of communication open, and speak up gently only when a natural opportunity arises.
What is the Romeo and Juliet effect in relationships?
Originally suggested by a 1972 study, the Romeo and Juliet effect posits that parental disapproval of a relationship increases the romantic involvement of the couple. Later research showed the dynamic is much messier and that parents ultimately lack a reliable lever to control a child's dating choices.
How should parents pray when worried about their child's romantic partner?
Instead of focusing your prayers entirely on removing the other person, use Psalm 25:12 as a guide to pray for your child's own vision, asking God to give them spiritual eyes to see the truth and the courage to act on it.
Back in 1972, a team of researchers set out to test
Bart Leger:something every worried parent wonders about. Whether pushing
Bart Leger:against the person your kid is dating or only backfires. They
Bart Leger:tracked dating and married couples for months, watching
Bart Leger:what happened as families pushed against the match. When the
Bart Leger:numbers came back, they seemed to confirm a parent's worst fear.
Bart Leger:The more the parents disapproved, the more in love the couple said
Bart Leger:they were. They called it the Romeo and Juliet effect. And the
Bart Leger:name stuck. For decades, this was their takeaway. Fight your
Bart Leger:kid's relationship and you only pour gas on it. We'll come back
Bart Leger:to what happened to that study. But
Bart Leger:first, welcome to Daily Devotions for Busy Lives. I'm
Bart Leger:Bart Leger. I've had this conversation with parents a few
Bart Leger:times. A mother and a father worried sick about who their son
Bart Leger:or their daughter is dating. What they want is something they
Bart Leger:can take home and say that will make their kids see it. And I
Bart Leger:don't have that something. I've never had it. What I've watched
Bart Leger:over the years is that the more a family pushes, the less access
Bart Leger:they potentially end up with. Then, they're worried and shut
Bart Leger:down at the same time. And which is the worst of both. So what I
Bart Leger:tell parents doesn't make them feel better right away. Because
Bart Leger:at the end of the day, it's in God's hands. And up to the child
Bart Leger:to listen to the Holy Spirit if they're a follower of Christ.
Bart Leger:Few things pull on a parent like watching your child with
Bart Leger:somebody you're worried about. You see the things they can't
Bart Leger:see yet. You've been around long enough to know how much a
Bart Leger:partner shapes a life. And you can already picture the next 10
Bart Leger:years of it. And you're walking a fine line every single day.
Bart Leger:Say too much and you push them closer to that person and
Bart Leger:further from you. Say nothing and you feel like you stood
Bart Leger:there and just watched it happen. A lot of parents end up doing
Bart Leger:both. You hold it in for weeks and then it comes out all of a
Bart Leger:sudden at the supper table in a tone you never planned on using.
Bart Leger:The psalmist gives us a dose of wisdom in Psalm 25 speaks to
Bart Leger:this very issue and many more. It's in Psalm 25, 12.
Bart Leger:Look at who does the work in that sense. He will show them.
Bart Leger:God does the showing. The path gets revealed to the person
Bart Leger:walking it and it's God who does the work. That ought to change
Bart Leger:what you ask God for. Most of us pray about the other person.
Bart Leger:Lord, get him out of our life. Lord, let this thing change and
Bart Leger:fall apart by Christmas. Psalm 25 points somewhere else
Bart Leger:entirely. Pray that your child can see. Pray for discernment in
Bart Leger:your son or daughter. Ask God to give them eyes for what's in
Bart Leger:front of them and the spine to act on what they see. That
Bart Leger:prayer has an advantage. The other one doesn't. It never
Bart Leger:requires you to be right about this person. You might be right.
Bart Leger:You might also be wrong. And every parent listening knows a
Bart Leger:family who was dead wrong about somebody. Either way, a child
Bart Leger:who sees clearly ends up where they need to be. Now, about
Bart Leger:speaking. The door does open sometimes. A question they ask
Bart Leger:you out of nowhere. A long drive with nobody else in the car.
Bart Leger:When it opens, you don't have to be too aggressive. Just keep it
Bart Leger:to what you've noticed.
Bart Leger:Then, other researchers went back and tried to repeat the
Bart Leger:study. And the original story didn't come back the same. It
Bart Leger:kind of fell apart. The Romeo and Juliet effect mostly didn't
Bart Leger:hold up. What they found was messier and more human.
Bart Leger:Sometimes, pressure pushed a couple closer. And sometimes,
Bart Leger:strong disapproval went right along with the breakup. There
Bart Leger:was no reliable lever a parent could pull to change what a
Bart Leger:child's heart wanted. The one thing the research kept
Bart Leger:confirming was the limit of a parent's control. You can pray
Bart Leger:and you can speak when the door opens. But the real work of
Bart Leger:turning a heart belongs to God. Look at what 50 years of
Bart Leger:studying this came back with. No lever or lever, whichever way
Bart Leger:you want to pronounce it. The first finding said pushing
Bart Leger:backfires. The retest said sometimes and sometimes the
Bart Leger:opposite. What survived all of it was the size of a parent's
Bart Leger:control or the span of their control, if you will, which is
Bart Leger:smaller than any of us want it to be. That's uncomfortable to
Bart Leger:hear. And it's a relief also. Because it means this was never
Bart Leger:resting on whether you found the right words. Here's today's
Bart Leger:challenge. Change your prayer today. For the next 30 days, aim
Bart Leger:it at your child's discernment. Lord, show her the path she
Bart Leger:should choose. Use the words of Psalm 25 if you want them
Bart Leger:because God gave them to us for this. And do one thing for the
Bart Leger:relationship you still have. Call your kid this week about
Bart Leger:something that has nothing to do with any of this. Ask about work
Bart Leger:or their school work if they're still in school. And tell them
Bart Leger:what the dog did. A door stays open by being used. Father, you
Bart Leger:said you would show the way to those who fear you. And we're
Bart Leger:asking you to do that for our children. For every parent
Bart Leger:listening who's worried today about their son or their
Bart Leger:daughter and who they're with, settle them and keep them close
Bart Leger:enough to be there when the door opens. Give our children eyes to
Bart Leger:see what's in front of them and the courage to act on what they
Bart Leger:see. In Jesus' name, amen. If you need prayer today, I'd love
Bart Leger:to hear from you. You can leave me a voicemail at
Bart Leger:dailydevotionsforbusylives.com slash voicemail. I listen to
Bart Leger:every single one, and it would be an honor to bring your name
Bart Leger:before the Lord. Thanks for joining me on Daily Devotions
Bart Leger:for Busy Lives. Remember, God is the one who shows a person the
Bart Leger:path. Pray for your child's eyes and keep the door open. Come
Bart Leger:back next time for more encouragement to help you look
Bart Leger:grounded in God's truth. Until then, God bless and have a great
Bart Leger:day.